Subscriptions Central AfricaEast AfricaHorn of AfricaIndian OceanNorth AfricaSouthern AfricaWest AfricaAfrica / World Agriculture - NutritionCulture - ArtsEconomy - DevelopmentEnvironment - NatureGay - LesbianGender - WomenHealthHuman rightsLabourMediaPoliticsScience - EducationSocietyTechnologyTravel - Leisure From Behind By Country By Topic Chronological Press Releases Partner Media Contact Us
wom020 Time to replace the carrot with the stick?


Women 
Time to replace the carrot with the stick?

Related items

News articles
» 10.12.2001 - SA campaign on violence against women closes 
» 14.08.2001 - Alcohol and domestic violence linked in Namibia 
» 22.06.2001 - Lack of information hampers African gender equality 
» 26.03.2001 - Shelter for battered women opened in Malawi 
» 21.02.2001 - Namibian Draft Domestic Violence Bill enters final stretch 
» 21.12.2000 - Gender issues paramount for Malawi police service 
» 15.12.2000 - Gender: Time to replace the carrot with the stick? 
» 12.12.2000 - Southern African women want action against violence 
» 05.12.2000 - Gender policy widely ignored in today's South African election 
» 04.12.2000 Botswana High Court leaves traditional marriages to customary courts 
» 21.11.2000 - Applause for recognition of polygamy 
» 17.11.2000 - South Africa: New Customary Marriages Act sees women as equal partners 
» 16.11.2000 - Maternal deaths on retreat in South Africa's North West Province 
» 06.11.2000 - Women's right biggest human rights problem in Gabon 
» 02.11.2000 - Women furious after bail release of rapist 
» 30.10.2000 - UN urges Gabon to prohibit polygamy 
» 21.09.2000 - Widespread violence against women in Africa documented 
» 01.06.2000 - UN releases most recent statistics on world's women 

Pages
News, Africa 
Afrol - Women 
Women & Gender News 
Lesotho Archive 
South Africa Archive 

Background
» Abuse of women escalates HIV infections in Africa 
» Women's health at risk in Africa 

In Internet
WOZA 
South African Government  
UNIFEM 

Misanet.com / IPS, 15 December - The next challenge for the governments of the Southern African Development Community (SADC) region may be to sign a legally binding international agreement to fight gender violence. This is a recommendation made in the SADC Addendum on gender violence but one that did not receive much attention in the region's assessment conference held in Maseru, Lesotho, this week. 

The Addendum to the region's declaration against gender violence commits member countries to specific action. This includes legal reform, effective services and public awareness campaigns.

It seems as if it is still easier to sign declarations than binding commitments.

- I would like to see us move in the medium term to legally binding instruments. But I would rather, in the short term, spend time in capacity building and enabling our countries to put measures in place instead of rushing to get legally binding instruments, says Athalia Molokomme, the head of the SADC Gender Unit. 

Gender violence is increasing across the region, as suggested in country reports presented to the inter-governmental meeting held this week. 

While governments have signed declarations to fight gender violence, they are not legally bound to adhere to their commitments. 

In the two years since the Addendum was signed in Durban, South Africa, only two countries have passed domestic violence legislation, a key commitment in the Addendum.

Namibia's Minister for Women's Affairs, Netumbo Ndaitwah, feels that it is not essential to bind countries. "Although it's not a legally binding instrument it is a useful working instrument," says Ndaitwah. 

With the 14 signatures of the SADC heads of government or state gracing both the SADC Declaration (1997) and the Addendum (1998) on gender violence, Ndaitwah sees sufficient political commitment. 

- We feel that since we have signatures of our head of states, it's a very important instrument that we have to make use of at all times as our guiding principles in dealing with issues of violence against women and children.

Molokomme agrees: "Although the addendum is not a legally binding instrument, it is not less important because it is an integral part of the gender declaration. "Even though a declaration is not legally binding, it's a very useful document because it sets regional norms and standards that agree on as a collective of countries," she says.

Molokomme says it does not make much sense to secure a legally binding instrument, on which SADC states can be sued, when the countries do not have the financial or political capacity to implement these measures. This carries a risk. "You can come up with legally binding instruments but some countries will not ratify it," she notes. 

But sometimes voluntarism does not deliver the goodies. SADC countries resolved in 1997 to enact laws such as sexual offences and domestic violence legislation to make various forms of violence against women clear defined crimes. Only two states, South Africa and Mauritius, have defined domestic violence as a specific crime.

Reparations for victims of gender violence, another recommendation in the Addendum, also received scant attention this week. This clause commits states to take appropriate measures to impose penalties and punishment for gender violence.

But not many countries appear to have warmed to the reparation suggestion and only South Africa reported that it could not afford reparations. Namibia is considering it. "When we were debating the Combating of Rape Bill in Namibia, the issue of reparations was raised. But it is not incorporated into the Act. But we are still seriously looking at it," Ndaitwah said. 

- The victim needs to somehow get some compensation. You can get counselling which will give you mental satisfaction. If you combine mental satisfaction with material satisfaction, you help the victim better than just giving one part.

by Lewis Machipisa, IPS


© IPS.

   You can contact afrol-Gender at elin.nordhagen@afrol.com