See also:
» 07.01.2011 - Record Zimbabwe debts to Equatorial Guinea
» 17.11.2010 - Zim diamond certification scandal revealed
» 13.10.2010 - Zimbabwe war of appointments
» 07.10.2010 - Chiefs, army, farmers "plotting Mugabe victory"
» 28.05.2010 - Zimbabwe talks dragging on
» 22.04.2010 - Zimbabwe spilt over Iran ties
» 15.04.2010 - Laws are made to work, not to be shelved, Mugabe
» 04.03.2010 - Britain no yet convinced to lift Zim sanctions

China wholesale online through

Houlihan's coupons

Finn autentiske matoppskrifter fra hele verden på
Gazpacho Børek Kartoffelsalat Taboulé Gulasj Albóndigas Cevapi Rougaille Japrak sarma Zwiebelbrot Klopse Giouvetsi Paella Pljeskavica Pica pau Pulpo a la gallega Flammkuchen Langosj Tapenade Chatsjapuri Pasulj Lassi Kartoffelpuffer Tortilla Raznjici Knödel Lentejas Bœuf bourguignon Korianderchutney Brenneslesuppe Proia Sæbsi kavurma Sardinske calamares

Autentiske matoppskrifter fra hele verden finner du på
Réunion Portugal Aserbajdsjan Serbia Tyskland Seychellene Bosnia Spania Libanon Belgia India Kroatia Hellas Italia Ungarn Komorene Georgia Mauritius Østerrike Romania Frankrike

Politics | Society

US was against Zim unity govt

Zimbabwe President Robert Mugabe ("the devil") and Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai ("a flawed figure")

© PM's office/afrol News
afrol News, 29 November
- In a 2007 report from the US Embassy in Harare, a possible national unity government in Zimbabwe is described as "less attractive." President Robert Mugabe is called "the devil" and Morgan Tsvangirai is described as "a flawed figure."

Among the 243,270 US State Department documents released this night by WikiLeaks, is a larger report from outgoing US Ambassador Christopher Dell, at the time still based in Harare, dated 13 July 2007. Here, "the End" (of the Mugabe regime) is analysed.

"The optimal outcome, of course, and the only one that doesn't bring with it a huge risk of violence and conflict, is a genuinely free and fair election, under international supervision," Ambassador Dell reported. But he did not have much faith in mediator Thabo Mbeki - then President of South Africa - when it came to achieve that goal.

Rather, Ambassador Dell correctly understood President Mbeki's priorities, which ended up in the negotiated establishment of a government of national unity in Zimbabwe. This unity government, headed by President Mugabe and current Prime Minister - then MDC opposition leader - Tsvangirai, still is in power in Harare.

Ambassador Dell described this option as "less attractive" in his report. A "South African-brokered transitional arrangement or government of national unity" was seen as "more likely to prolong than resolve the crisis and we must guard against letting Pretoria dictate an outcome which perpetuates the status quo at the expense of real change and reform."

President Mbeki in the report is criticised for being more worried "about the chaos to its north" than about real change and democratic reform in Zimbabwe. "Mbeki has always favoured stability and in his mind this means a [ruling party] ZANU-PF-led [government of national unity], with perhaps a few [opposition] MDC additions."

Discussing what "the end [will] look like," Ambassador Dell also lists other possible "less attractive" scenarios. "A popular uprising would inevitably entail a bloodbath, even if it were ultimately successful; Mugabe's sudden, unexpected death would set off a stampede for power among ZANU-PF heavy weights; a palace coup, whether initiated within ZANU-PF or from the military - in which Mugabe is removed, killed, exiled or otherwise disposed of, could well devolve into open conflict between the contending successors."

The analysis leaves it clear that, even though President Mugabe is demonised by the US diplomat, the alternatives to Zimbabwe's seasoned leaders are far from perfect. "Zimbabwe's opposition is far from ideal and I leave convinced that had we had different partners we could have achieved more already," Ambassador Dell writes.

The MDC leadership was said to have "little executive experience and will require massive hand holding and assistance should they ever come to power." Ambassador Dell called for the US and other donors to stand ready for this "massive hand holding" to make sure Zim

US Ambassador Christopher Dell with Secretary of State Hillary Clinton

© US Dept of State/afrol News
babwe experiences fast advances should the MDC take over.

MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai is described as "a brave, committed man and, by and large, a democrat. He is also the only player on the scene right now with real star quality and the ability to rally the masses. But Tsvangarai is also a flawed figure, not readily open to advice, indecisive and with questionable judgment in selecting those around him."

Mr Tsvangirai further was described as "the indispensable element for opposition success, but possibly an albatross around their necks once in power. In short, he is a kind of Lech Walesa [Poland's first post-Communism leader] character: Zimbabwe needs him, but should not rely on his executive abilities to lead the country's recovery."

Ambassador Dell is even more concerned about other MDC heavyweights. Arthur Mutambara is described as "attracted to radical, anti-western rhetoric." Welshman Ncube had "proven to be a deeply divisive and destructive player in the opposition ranks and the sooner he is pushed off the stage, the better."

The US diplomat is worried that, "with few exceptions - Tendayi Biti, Nelson Chamisa - the talent is thin below the top ranks [of the MDC]. The great saving grace of the opposition is likely to be found in the diaspora. Most of Zimbabwe's best professionals, entrepreneurs, businessmen and women, etc., have fled the country," the report sums up.

But the worst of all possible leaders in Zimbabwe, according to Ambassador Dell's report, is incumbent President Mugabe. The "Old Man" is described as "more clever and more ruthless than any other politician."

"To give the devil his due, he is a brilliant tactician and has long thrived on his ability to abruptly change the rules of the game, radicalise the political dynamic and force everyone else to react to his agenda," the US diplomat explains.

But the powers of President Mugabe were described as diminishing, as the Zimbabwean leader had plaid out most of his cards. Mr Mugabe was "fundamentally hampered" by "his ego and belief in his own infallibility; his obsessive focus on the past as a justification for everything in the present and future;" and "his deep ignorance on economic issues," which was "coupled with the belief that his 18 doctorates give him the authority to suspend the laws of economics, including supply and demand."

Since the July 2007 report, Ambassador Dell changed office and is now the US Ambassador in Kosovo. President Mugabe is still in power, with Mr Tsvangirai holding the office of Prime Minister. Next year may see an end to the national unity government, as Zimbabwe is preparing for elections. It remains to be seen if 2011 could see the end of the Mugabe regime.

- Create an e-mail alert for Zimbabwe news
- Create an e-mail alert for Politics news
- Create an e-mail alert for Society news

    Printable version

On the Afrol News front page now

Rwanda succeeds including citizens in formal financial sector

afrol News - It is called "financial inclusion", and it is a key government policy in Rwanda. The goal is that, by 2020, 90 percent of the population is to have and actively use bank accounts. And in only four years, financial inclusion has doubled in Rwanda.

Famine warning: "South Sudan is imploding"

afrol News - The UN's humanitarian agencies now warn about a devastating famine in Sudan and especially in South Sudan, where the situation is said to be "imploding". Relief officials are appealing to donors to urgently fund life-saving activities in the two countries.
Panic in West Africa after Ebola outbreak in Guinea

afrol News - Fear is spreading all over West Africa after the health ministry in Guinea confirmed the first Ebola outbreak in this part of Africa. According to official numbers, at least 86 are infected and 59 are dead as a result of this very contagious disease.
Ethiopia tightens its already strict anti-gay laws

afrol News - It is already a crime being homosexual in Ethiopia, but parliament is now making sure the anti-gay laws will be applied in practical life. No pardoning of gays will be allowed in future, but activist fear this only is a signal of further repression being prepared.
Ethiopia plans Africa's biggest dam

afrol News / Africa Renewal - Ethiopia's ambitious plan to build a US$ 4.2 billion dam in the Benishangul-Gumuz region, 40 km from its border with Sudan, is expected to provide 6,000 megawatts of electricity, enough for its population plus some excess it can sell to neighbouring countries.

front page | news | countries | archive | currencies | news alerts login | about afrol News | contact | advertise | español 

©  afrol News. Reproducing or buying afrol News' articles.

   You can contact us at